Federal practice only

Request a consultation

News · Court decisions

When a cooperating witness refuses to answer at trial

By Brandon SampleCourt decisions

On November 12, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed Javoni Butler's drug and money-laundering convictions and his 444-month sentence. The main trial issue was a cooperating government witness who refused to answer some defense questions and later said he had been under the influence of fentanyl while he testified. The opinion is marked "Unpublished" and was issued per curiam, meaning it is not signed by one judge. The opinion is United States v. Butler, No. 25-2651 (8th Cir. Nov. 12, 2026). Read the decision (PDF).

The charges and the trial

The case came from the Northern District of Iowa (Chief Judge C.J. Williams). Judges Gruender, Kelly, and Kobes decided the appeal. (Butler.)

The opinion says that during 2022 and 2023, Butler bought thousands of fentanyl pills in Mexico for distribution in Iowa. Officers found a gun under the hood of his car, and fentanyl and cash at a house belonging to his girlfriend's mother. Wiretap messages showed he sent distributors to that house to pick up drugs. (Butler.)

He was charged with conspiracy to distribute a controlled substance under 21 U.S.C. § 846, possession with intent to distribute under 21 U.S.C. § 841, and international money laundering under 18 U.S.C. § 1956(a)(2)(B)(i). A jury convicted him after hearing sixteen witnesses. (Butler.)

The witness who invoked the Fifth Amendment

A cooperating witness is a person who agrees to help the government, often in hope of a lower sentence in his own case. This witness testified that he had bought fentanyl from Butler. On cross-examination, which is the questioning by the other side, defense counsel asked how the witness could afford the large amount of pills he described when his take-home pay was much lower. The witness invoked his right to remain silent, and the district court ended questions about his finances. (Butler.)

The Fifth Amendment protects any person from being compelled to be a witness against himself. That privilege belongs to witnesses too, not only to the person on trial. The Sixth Amendment gives the accused the right to confront the witnesses against him and to have compulsory process, meaning the court's power to bring witnesses to testify.

The court of appeals held that the district court did not abuse its discretion by letting the witness invoke the privilege. It quoted an earlier Eighth Circuit case, United States v. Blaylock, for the rule that "an accused's right to compulsory process must yield to a witness's Fifth Amendment privilege not to give testimony that would tend to incriminate him or her." (Butler.)

The court also held there was no violation of the right to confrontation. The questions Butler wanted to ask, the opinion says, would only impeach the witness. To impeach is to attack a witness's believability. The questions did not explore the substantive matters the witness had testified to on direct examination. The opinion relied on United States v. Long Pumpkin, which draws that line between collateral credibility questions and questions about the substance of the testimony. (Butler.)

A witness under the influence while testifying

Later, the same witness disclosed that he was under the influence of fentanyl during trial. Butler asked for a new trial. Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 33, a court may grant a new trial if the interest of justice requires it.

The court of appeals held that denying a new trial was not an abuse of discretion. It treated the witness's impairment as impeachment evidence. Under the Eighth Circuit cases the opinion cites, new evidence supports a new trial only if it is "material," "not merely . . . impeaching," and probably "would produce an acquittal at the new trial." The court said this evidence would not lead to acquittal given what it called the overwhelming other evidence of guilt. (Butler.)

The other issues

The court held the evidence was sufficient for a reasonable jury to convict on all charges, pointing to the pills obtained in Mexico, their transport to Iowa, and a wire transfer to his supplier. (Butler.)

On sentencing, the court found no clear error in applying the firearm increase in U.S.S.G. § 2D1.1(b)(1). Butler had constructive possession of the gun under the hood, meaning control over the place where it was found, and he used the car to move fentanyl. The court also held the within-Guidelines sentence was not substantively unreasonable. (Butler.)

Butler also filed his own supplemental brief. The court rejected his claim that he did not possess the drugs at the house, because he directed a distributor there to fill orders. It rejected his claim under the Speedy Trial Act because the superseding indictment reset his clock. The opinion quotes an earlier Eighth Circuit case: when a newly indicted defendant is joined with one whose clock is already running, that clock resets. (Butler.)

What the opinion does and does not decide

This is one unpublished decision. It is not binding precedent. It shows how this court treats two trial problems. When a government witness invokes the Fifth Amendment on questions that go only to credibility, the court may end those questions without violating the Confrontation Clause. When a witness's impairment comes to light after trial, it is treated as impeachment evidence, which rarely supports a new trial when other evidence of guilt is strong. (Butler.)

Source: United States v. Butler, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, No. 25-2651. Read the source

← All news

Request a consultation