On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit reversed a district court order that had suppressed evidence found on a man's electronic devices. The court held that the officers who searched the devices reasonably relied on a warrant a magistrate had approved. It did not decide whether that warrant was supported by probable cause. The opinion is precedential, so it binds federal courts in Delaware, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The case is United States v. Cain, No. 25-2721 (3d Cir. Nov. 17, 2026). Read the decision (PDF).
The four warrants
According to the opinion, the parents of two young children told police in October 2023 that Jason Cain had repeatedly exposed himself to the children while they were in his care. A Pennsylvania State Trooper applied for a warrant to search his home and his person for electronic devices. The supporting affidavit, a sworn statement of facts, said that he had recorded the children with a video camera and had sent their mother photographs of them. A county prosecutor approved the application, and a magistrate issued the warrant. It allowed police to seize every electronic device and to search the devices for photographs or videos of the two children. (Cain.)
Officers seized the devices. Three days later the Trooper obtained a second warrant, which added sexually explicit images of children to what police could search for. A third warrant covered hidden cameras in the home. A fourth covered items that Cain's wife later found and turned over.
A federal grand jury indicted Cain on seven counts under 18 U.S.C. § 2251(a) and two counts under 18 U.S.C. § 2252(a)(4)(B). An indictment is a formal written charge, not a finding of guilt.
What the district court did
Cain filed a motion to suppress, which asks a court to bar the government from using evidence obtained in violation of the Constitution. The district court granted it. It held that the first two warrants were not supported by probable cause, that the good faith exception did not apply, and that the first two warrants tainted the later ones. The government appealed, which 18 U.S.C. § 3731 allows it to do from an order suppressing evidence. (Cain.)
The good faith exception
The Fourth Amendment bars "unreasonable searches and seizures" and says that warrants may issue only "upon probable cause." Evidence taken in violation of that rule is often excluded from trial under the exclusionary rule.
There is an exception. Under United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897 (1984), as the Third Circuit described it, suppression is not warranted when evidence was "obtained in objectively reasonable reliance" on a warrant that is later found to lack probable cause. The Cain opinion, quoting Leon, says a warrant issued by a magistrate "normally suffices" to show that an officer acted in good faith. One limit the opinion applies is an affidavit "so lacking in indicia of probable cause" that belief in it is "entirely unreasonable."
Why the court of appeals reversed
The panel said it needed to examine only the first warrant. It gave these reasons for finding good faith:
- Cain did not claim that anything in the warrant application was false.
- The affidavit described interviews with the two children, evidence that he had photographed and recorded them, and the Trooper's opinion, based on training and experience, about how people keep such images.
- A prosecutor approved the application before it went to the magistrate. The court cited Messerschmidt v. Millender, 565 U.S. 535 (2012), for treating that step as support for an officer's good faith.
The district court had read the first warrant as a search for child pornography. The Third Circuit disagreed. The warrant "said nothing about child pornography" and authorized a search only for images of the two named children. For that reason, the court said two of its earlier decisions that refused to apply the good faith exception were "not relevant here."
The court then turned to the other warrants. Because the first warrant already allowed a search of the same devices, any error in the second one was harmless. And because officers could reasonably believe that what they learned under the first warrant was lawfully obtained, good faith also covered the third and fourth warrants.
The court also rejected the argument that the first two warrants were general warrants, meaning warrants that give officers "unbridled discretion" to rummage through a person's belongings. A warrant is not general, the court said, merely because it lists a broad category of items. (Cain.)
What the opinion does and does not decide
The court did not hold that the first warrant was supported by probable cause. It set that question aside and decided the appeal on good faith alone. It also did not decide whether the second warrant was lawful.
The panel added a caution for future cases. It said its task "would have been far easier" if the affidavit had stated how images of the two children would help the investigation. When police seek evidence of a crime rather than contraband, the court said, a judge must assess whether there is probable cause to believe the evidence "will aid in a particular apprehension or conviction."
The decision sends the case back to the district court for further proceedings. It does not decide guilt.
Our guides to a motion to suppress and appeals in the Third Circuit explain more.
Source: United States v. Cain, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 25-2721. Read the source
More court decisions
Fifth Circuit: Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales
A published Fifth Circuit opinion says the Second Amendment's text covers firearm sales and sends an unlicensed gun dealing case back for more review.
Sixth Circuit Rejects Two Felon Gun Ban Challenges
Two unpublished Sixth Circuit opinions affirmed felon-in-possession convictions and kept the burden of showing non-dangerousness on the accused.
Fifth Circuit Affirms Lewis Despite Trial Errors
An unpublished Fifth Circuit opinion affirmed drug conspiracy and gun verdicts although some officer testimony at trial was admitted in error.