Federal practice only

Request a consultation

News · Court decisions

Who must prove dangerousness in a felon gun case

By Brandon SampleCourt decisions

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit rejected Second Amendment challenges to the federal felon gun ban in two separate appeals. In both, the court applied its 2024 decision in United States v. Williams. Under that decision, a person with a felony conviction who challenges the ban must show that he is not dangerous. Neither opinion is recommended for publication, so neither is binding precedent. The first is United States v. Jones, No. 25-1975 (6th Cir. Nov. 16, 2026). Read the decision (PDF). The second is United States v. Jordan, No. 25-3685 (6th Cir. Nov. 16, 2026). Read the Jordan decision (PDF).

The law being challenged

18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) makes it a federal crime for a person convicted of "a crime punishable by imprisonment for a term exceeding one year" to possess a firearm or ammunition. The Second Amendment protects "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms."

A challenge to a statute can take two forms. A facial challenge says the law is invalid in every case. An as-applied challenge says the law cannot be used against this particular person on these facts.

The test the Sixth Circuit uses

The Jones opinion describes the two-part test from the Supreme Court's decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. A court first asks whether the Second Amendment's "plain text covers" the conduct. If it does, the government must show that the law is "consistent with the Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation." (Jones.)

The Sixth Circuit applied that test to § 922(g)(1) in United States v. Williams, 113 F.4th 637 (6th Cir. 2024). As Jones summarizes it, Williams held that the Second Amendment's text covers what the statute regulates, but that the statute fits a historical tradition of barring groups deemed dangerous from having guns unless a person in the group showed he "posed no danger to peace." Williams upheld the statute on its face. It left room for as-applied challenges where a person with a felony conviction can show that he is not dangerous. (Jones.)

Jones: an argument about who carries the burden

Ryan Alexander Jones pleaded guilty in the Eastern District of Michigan to possessing a firearm as a felon. He was sentenced to 51 months in prison. His facial and as-applied Second Amendment challenges failed in the district court. The court of appeals reviewed them de novo, meaning fresh. (Jones.)

Jones conceded that Williams defeats his facial challenge. He also admitted that his prior offenses, which the opinion says include a robbery and assault conviction, fall within a category of crimes for which the court should consider him dangerous. He argued instead that Williams was wrong to put the burden on him, because Bruen puts the burden on the government.

The panel gave two answers. First, as a later panel, it would be bound by Williams even if it thought Williams was wrong. Second, the court said Jones was "confusing different burdens." One is the government's burden to show a historical tradition that supports the regulation. The other is the burden of proving an exception to a rule the government has already justified. Williams held that the government met the first burden for § 922(g)(1), which left the second for people who bring as-applied challenges. Because Jones conceded he could not show he was not dangerous, his as-applied challenge failed. (Jones.)

Jones also argued that § 922(g)(1) exceeds Congress's power under the Commerce Clause, the part of the Constitution that lets Congress regulate interstate commerce. He raised that point for the first time in his reply brief. The court said it came too late and, in any event, is foreclosed by circuit precedent. (Jones.)

Jordan: the record showed dangerousness

Reggie Jordan's case came from the Northern District of Ohio. According to the opinion, police saw a social media video of him at a gun range, obtained a warrant, and found six guns in his apartment. A grand jury indicted him under § 922(g)(1). He moved to dismiss the indictment, the formal written charge, on Second Amendment grounds. The district court denied the motion, and a jury convicted him. (Jordan.)

The court of appeals again applied Williams. It said circuit precedent forecloses the facial challenge and that Jordan bore the "burden to demonstrate that he is not dangerous." He had a prior conviction for aggravated robbery, in which the opinion says he struck the victim in the head with a gun. He also had two drug-trafficking convictions. The court held that the record gave "ample grounds to justify Jordan's disarmament." (Jordan.)

The court also affirmed Jordan's 120-month sentence, which runs consecutively to a state sentence, meaning one after the other. (Jordan.)

What the opinions do and do not decide

The opinions apply existing Sixth Circuit law to two records. They do not hold that an as-applied challenge can never succeed. Jones conceded the dangerousness question, and Jordan's record included a robbery committed with a gun. Neither opinion addresses a person whose only prior convictions are nonviolent.

They show how the Sixth Circuit, which hears federal appeals from Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee, frames the question: the person challenging the charge carries the burden on dangerousness, and the court looks to the prior record. We wrote earlier about how the en banc Third Circuit handled similar challenges.

Our guides to federal gun charges and appeals in the Sixth Circuit explain more.

Source: United States v. Jones, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 25-1975. Read the source

← All news

Request a consultation