Federal practice only

Request a consultation

News · Court decisions

When officer testimony errors do not undo a verdict

By Brandon SampleCourt decisions

On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed Deablo Deshon Lewis's drug conspiracy and firearm convictions. The court agreed that some testimony at his trial should not have come in. It affirmed anyway, because his lawyer had not raised those objections at trial and the rest of the evidence was strong. The opinion is per curiam, meaning it is not signed by one judge, and is not designated for publication. It is United States v. Lewis, No. 25-40716 (5th Cir. Nov. 13, 2026). Read the decision (PDF).

The charges and the trial

The case came from the Eastern District of Texas. A jury convicted Lewis on two counts. Count One was conspiring to distribute and possess with intent to distribute a controlled substance under 21 U.S.C. § 846 and § 841(b)(1)(B). Count Two was using or carrying a firearm during a drug-trafficking crime, or possessing one in furtherance of that crime, under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c)(1)(A). He was sentenced to 240 months in prison and five years of supervised release. (Lewis.)

Was a gun possessed "in furtherance" of drug trafficking

Lewis argued the evidence on the gun count was insufficient. He had moved for acquittal at trial, which asks the judge to rule that the evidence cannot support a conviction. (Fed. R. Crim. P. 29.) So the court reviewed the question fresh, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict.

Under Fifth Circuit law, the opinion says, the government must show more than mere possession. It must show that the possession "actually furthered the drug trafficking offense." Courts look at factors such as the type of drug activity, whether the gun was loaded and accessible, and how close it was to drugs. (Lewis.)

Officers found substantial quantities of drugs, digital scales, and two loaded firearms at Lewis's residence. The guns were in his bedroom, in the same dresser as the drugs but in a separate drawer, with his identifying documents. A co-conspirator, meaning another person in the same agreement, testified to seeing Lewis with a gun in his vehicle while he sold drugs. The court said the government did not have to prove drugs were sold where the guns were found. (Lewis.)

Officers repeating what others told them

The Sixth Amendment gives the accused the right to confront the witnesses against him. The opinion explains that officers may not relay statements from people who do not testify, when those statements directly point to the defendant's guilt, "under the guise of explaining their investigation." (Lewis.)

Lewis challenged testimony about the information that first identified him as a drug dealer, communications around a planned buy-bust operation, statements gathered at a second residence, and statements that he was known to carry guns. The government conceded that some of this testimony was clear or obvious error. (Lewis.)

The objection had not been made at trial. That mattered. When an issue is not raised in the trial court, the court of appeals reviews only for plain error. (Fed. R. Crim. P. 52(b).) The person appealing must show a clear or obvious error that affected his substantial rights. The court held Lewis did not show an effect on his substantial rights. It pointed to the drugs, scales and guns, his own statement that he had a source of supply for pills, text messages about supplying drugs on consignment, and the co-conspirator's testimony. (Lewis.)

An officer's opinions about the drug trade

An officer, who shares the last name Lewis, testified about the opioid epidemic, drug-trafficking practices, the items found in the search, and the meaning of text messages. On appeal, the defense argued this was expert testimony and legal opinion.

A lay witness is one who is not testifying as an expert. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 701, a lay witness's opinion must be rationally based on the witness's own perception and may not rest on specialized knowledge covered by the expert rule, Rule 702.

At trial, the defense objected to part of this testimony only as speculation. The court said that did not preserve the different theories raised on appeal, so plain-error review applied again. It held that most of the testimony rested on the officer's firsthand experience in this and earlier investigations, which Fifth Circuit cases allow. To the extent other parts needed specialized knowledge, or interpreted ordinary language the jury could judge for itself, the court held the other evidence was strong enough that Lewis's substantial rights were not affected. (Lewis.)

The court also found that the officer "impermissibly opined" on whether Lewis's conduct met the legal definition of a conspiracy. Again, it held the error did not affect his substantial rights. (Lewis.)

Cumulative error

Lewis last argued that the errors together denied him a fair trial. Quoting an earlier case, the court said "this was not a perfect trial, and there were errors," but held that Lewis received a fair one. (Lewis.)

What the opinion does and does not decide

This is one unpublished decision about one trial record. It does not approve the testimony the government conceded was error. It shows that an objection not made at trial, or made on a different ground, is reviewed only for plain error, where strong remaining evidence can end the claim. (Lewis.)

Our guides to a federal trial, federal gun charges, and appeals in the Fifth Circuit explain more.

Source: United States v. Lewis, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 25-40716. Read the source

← All news

Request a consultation