Cruz Zermeno was a passenger in a car stopped on Interstate 40 in New Mexico. The Tenth Circuit affirmed the denial of his motion to suppress the drugs found after that stop. The officer said the driver was following another vehicle too closely. The court held that this gave reasonable suspicion for the stop, that the district court made its own findings, and that the officer's motive did not undo an objectively justified seizure. The clerk filed the order and judgment in United States v. Zermeno, No. 26-2087, on November 6, 2026. It is not binding precedent. Read the decision (PDF).
What happened
On the morning of November 20, 2024, Zermeno was a passenger in a black Acura. Mario Gonsalez Jr. was driving. Guillermo Garcia Jr. was also in the car. The opinion describes Juan Rodriguez as a Homeland Security Investigations task force officer. Rodriguez stopped the Acura for following another vehicle too closely.
The opinion quotes N.M. Stat. Ann. § 66-7-318(A) (2022), the traffic rule Rodriguez relied on. As quoted there, a driver "shall not follow another vehicle more closely than is reasonable and prudent, having due regard for the speed of the vehicles and the traffic upon and the condition of the highway."
Rodriguez asked the passengers to roll the back windows down and smelled marijuana. He had Gonsalez step out while he wrote a warning citation and asked about travel plans. He checked the vehicle identification number, spoke with the passengers about their travel, and confirmed that the numbers matched Gonsalez's paperwork. He then asked Gonsalez if he would answer more questions. Gonsalez agreed and said marijuana was in the car. The opinion says Rodriguez told him he was going to search the Acura because marijuana is a controlled substance. Rodriguez opened the trunk and found a plastic garbage bag with about 25 pounds of methamphetamine.
Zermeno was charged in federal court and entered a conditional guilty plea. One count was conspiracy to distribute 500 grams or more of a mixture or substance containing methamphetamine, under 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1) and § 846. The other was possession with intent to distribute methamphetamine, under § 841(a)(1) and (b)(1)(A) and 18 U.S.C. § 2. Section 2 is the aiding-and-abetting statute. A person who aids, abets, counsels, commands, induces, or procures a federal offense is punishable as a principal.
A conditional plea is a guilty plea that leaves a specified pretrial ruling open for appeal. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(a)(2) allows that only with the consent of the court and the government. Zermeno reserved the denial of his motion to suppress. A motion to suppress asks the court to keep evidence out of the case. The district court later sentenced him to 120 months in prison. This appeal is about the stop.
Before the plea, Zermeno argued there was no sign a traffic violation had occurred. The district court held a hearing. Rodriguez testified. The court also reviewed the dashcam recording and the citation, then denied the motion. It credited his testimony that, from training and experience, he saw the Acura following at an unreasonably close distance. The court said it was "ill-suited to second-guess this exercise of discretion." It also rejected the argument that the dashcam failed to show the Acura was too close. Even if the video was unclear, the court said, Rodriguez had reasonable suspicion, and the "observation that Gonsalez was following the truck trailer too closely was, at most, a reasonable mistake."
How a court reviews the stop
The Fourth Amendment protects people against unreasonable searches and seizures. A traffic stop is a seizure. The Zermeno opinion says a stop is reasonable when it is justified at the start and the officer's actions during the stop stay reasonably related to the purpose of the stop. It cites United States v. Gomez-Arzate, 981 F.3d 832, 838 (10th Cir. 2020), for that description.
Reasonable suspicion, as the opinion uses the term, is "a particularized and objective basis for suspecting the particular person stopped of breaking the law." The opinion takes that definition from Gomez-Arzate, which quotes Heien v. North Carolina, 574 U.S. 54, 60 (2014).
On a suppression appeal, the opinion says the court views the evidence in the light most favorable to the government, accepts the district court's findings of fact unless they are clearly erroneous, and decides the Fourth Amendment question anew. It cites United States v. Baker, 108 F.4th 1241, 1246 (10th Cir. 2024). The opinion uses United States v. Cash, 733 F.3d 1264, 1273 (10th Cir. 2013), for clear error: the appeals court is not left with a definite and firm conviction that a mistake was made.
The appeal came from the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico, No. 1:24-cr-01819. Jurisdiction to review the final judgment is 28 U.S.C. § 1291. The panel decided the case on the briefs, without oral argument, under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 34(f) and Tenth Circuit Rule 34.1(G).
What the court decided
Zermeno argued that Rodriguez could not have seen the Acura following too closely, and that the dashcam showed clear error. The appeals court disagreed. The district court credited Rodriguez. He said he saw the Acura within three car lengths of the vehicle ahead. He was about a quarter mile behind. He placed the observation around mile marker 128 or 129, and he issued the citation at mile marker 129. The panel said that account showed he was not so far away that he could not form an impression of a traffic violation on the interstate.
The dashcam showed a black Acura trailing a white semi-trailer. Rodriguez reached the Acura soon after he accelerated. Nothing on the video showed that the Acura was not following too closely. The panel said nothing in the record would have impaired his view of the interstate. It was reasonable to conclude a violation had occurred and to make the stop. Citing Baker and Cash, the panel was not left with a definite and firm conviction that a mistake had been made.
Zermeno also argued that the district court did not find the facts itself and leaned too far on Rodriguez. The opinion describes United States v. McGregor, 158 F.4th 1082, 1091 (10th Cir. 2025), as leaving credibility, and the weight of the evidence, to the trial court, with due deference on appeal. It also says a reviewing court defers to a trained officer's ability to tell innocent conduct from suspicious conduct. The panel said the district court explained its decision and assessed the evidence. Deference to the testimony that a violation occurred was proper. Disagreement with that choice did not mean the district court had given up the factfinder's role.
The last argument asked the court to depart from Whren v. United States, 517 U.S. 806 (1996). Whren holds that an officer's subjective motive does not invalidate behavior that is objectively justifiable under the Fourth Amendment. The opinion quotes Whren at 811. Outside inventory searches and administrative inspections, the Supreme Court has "repeatedly held" that an officer's motive does not invalidate "objectively justifiable behavior under the Fourth Amendment." The Tenth Circuit said it is bound by that precedent. It cited United States v. Hahn, 186 F.4th 728, 748 (10th Cir. 2026), for the point that a lower court is bound by the holding and reasoning of a Supreme Court decision. Rodriguez's subjective intent was irrelevant. The opinion cites Whren at 814 for that point.
The panel affirmed. Its written analysis covers those three arguments. It states the general rule that actions during a stop must relate to the stop's purpose. It does not separately decide whether the smell of marijuana, the driver's admission, or the trunk search would stand if the stop itself had been unlawful.
What the order is, and is not
This is an order and judgment, not a published opinion. The footnote says it is not binding precedent, except for law of the case, res judicata, and collateral estoppel. It may be cited for its persuasive value under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1 and Tenth Circuit Rule 32.1. The Tenth Circuit clerk posts the local rules.
What it means in a federal case
- A federal drug prosecution can begin with a traffic stop. In Zermeno, a task force officer used a following-too-closely observation on an interstate. The conditional plea kept the suppression ruling open for this appeal.
- Reasonable suspicion is the standard for the stop. The panel accepted the credited account of three car lengths, the officer's distance behind the car, and the mile marker that matched the citation. An unclear dashcam did not, on this record, overturn that account.
- Credibility at the suppression hearing stays with the district court. As the opinion describes McGregor, the appeals court defers to that credibility decision and to a trained officer's reading of the driving.
- Motive is not the test under Whren. When the stop is objectively justified, the officer's reason for wanting to make it does not make the seizure unreasonable. The panel said it could not set that Supreme Court rule aside.
- The order is persuasive, not binding, in a later Tenth Circuit case. The footnote points to Tenth Circuit Rule 32.1. The appeal arose in the District of New Mexico.
Our guides to a motion to suppress, a federal investigation, federal drug trafficking, and appeals in the Tenth Circuit explain the hearing, the charges, and how a circuit ruling is reviewed.
Source: United States v. Zermeno, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 26-2087. Read the source
More court decisions
Fifth Circuit: Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales
A published Fifth Circuit opinion says the Second Amendment's text covers firearm sales and sends an unlicensed gun dealing case back for more review.
Third Circuit Reverses Suppression Under Good Faith Rule
A precedential Third Circuit opinion reversed a suppression order, holding that police relied in good faith on a warrant to search electronic devices.
Sixth Circuit Rejects Two Felon Gun Ban Challenges
Two unpublished Sixth Circuit opinions affirmed felon-in-possession convictions and kept the burden of showing non-dangerousness on the accused.